Core Path · L5.3.08

Normal against lognormal dynamics

14 minHull-WhiteBlack-KarasinskiVolatility smileNegative ratesModel risk

By the end you will be able to

  1. 1Fit a normal and a lognormal short-rate model to the same swaption and compare the smiles they imply with the market's.
  2. 2Explain why a model's smile comes from its dynamics (how vol depends on the level of rates) and hardly at all from its mean reversion.
  3. 3Compare the laws of the short rate the two models imply: the same mean, different tails, and a chance of negative rates in one only.
  4. 4Say what the choice costs on the bank's options, and how prudent valuation treats it.

Why it matters

The bank values its swaptions and its mortgage prepayment option with Hull-White. A validator refits Black-Karasinski to the same 5y × 5y swaption, gets the same 90bp at the money, and then prices a receiver struck 200bp lower: £243.9k on £100m, against Hull-White's £606.3k. Both models fit everything they were asked to fit. L5.2.09: Normal volatility and negative rates showed the market quotes normal vols because rates got close to zero; this lesson shows what that choice means inside a short-rate model.