Know these first
- L5.2.09: Normal volatility and negative rates
By the end you will be able to
- 1Fit a normal and a lognormal short-rate model to the same swaption and compare the smiles they imply with the market's.
- 2Explain why a model's smile comes from its dynamics (how vol depends on the level of rates) and hardly at all from its mean reversion.
- 3Compare the laws of the short rate the two models imply: the same mean, different tails, and a chance of negative rates in one only.
- 4Say what the choice costs on the bank's options, and how prudent valuation treats it.
Why it matters
The bank values its swaptions and its mortgage prepayment option with Hull-White. A validator refits Black-Karasinski to the same 5y × 5y swaption, gets the same 90bp at the money, and then prices a receiver struck 200bp lower: £243.9k on £100m, against Hull-White's £606.3k. Both models fit everything they were asked to fit. L5.2.09: Normal volatility and negative rates showed the market quotes normal vols because rates got close to zero; this lesson shows what that choice means inside a short-rate model.