Know these first
- L5.1.05: The Black-Scholes formula
- L5.1.08: Implied volatility
By the end you will be able to
- 1Explain why rates markets quote normal (basis point) vols, and price with Bachelier's model.
- 2Convert a normal vol into a lognormal one and back, exactly by root finding and with Hagan's approximation: 86bp on the 1y × 10y is 20.72% in Black terms.
- 3Show why Black-76 fails when rates are negative, and price with a shifted lognormal model whose vol depends on the shift (94.6%, 32.4%, 19.6% for the same option).
- 4Place the negative-rate years in the euro area, Switzerland, Japan and the UK gilt market, and read the MOVE index.
Why it matters
In 2002 Hagan and his co-authors wrote that, yen traders apart, “most traders prefer to quote prices in terms of Black (log normal) volatilities”. By June 2015, with euro money-market rates below zero, a presentation to the ECB's Money Market Contact Group reported that cap and floor vols “are quoted as Normal”, and that for swaptions market participants had opted for a “displaced lognormal model”. Black-76 had not become wrong overnight: wherever forwards were below zero, it had become impossible. This lesson is about the quote that replaced it.