Core Path · L5.2.09

Normal volatility and negative rates

14 minNormal volatilityBachelierNegative ratesShifted lognormalMOVE index

By the end you will be able to

  1. 1Explain why rates markets quote normal (basis point) vols, and price with Bachelier's model.
  2. 2Convert a normal vol into a lognormal one and back, exactly by root finding and with Hagan's approximation: 86bp on the 1y × 10y is 20.72% in Black terms.
  3. 3Show why Black-76 fails when rates are negative, and price with a shifted lognormal model whose vol depends on the shift (94.6%, 32.4%, 19.6% for the same option).
  4. 4Place the negative-rate years in the euro area, Switzerland, Japan and the UK gilt market, and read the MOVE index.

Why it matters

In 2002 Hagan and his co-authors wrote that, yen traders apart, “most traders prefer to quote prices in terms of Black (log normal) volatilities”. By June 2015, with euro money-market rates below zero, a presentation to the ECB's Money Market Contact Group reported that cap and floor vols “are quoted as Normal”, and that for swaptions market participants had opted for a “displaced lognormal model”. Black-76 had not become wrong overnight: wherever forwards were below zero, it had become impossible. This lesson is about the quote that replaced it.