Know these first
- L5.2.09: Normal volatility and negative rates
By the end you will be able to
- 1Build a Black-Derman-Toy tree: bottom rates fitted to the curve by forward induction, and ln r spreading as σ√t.
- 2Build Black-Karasinski on Hull and White's tree, with Newton's method for each step's shift, and explain why its rates stay positive.
- 3Fit Black-Karasinski's σ to a swaption by the secant method: 22.30% for the 5y × 5y at 90bp, in 5 trees.
- 4Say what a lognormal short rate gives up: closed forms, negative rates and thin upper tails.
Why it matters
Hull-White lets rates go below zero. For years that looked like a flaw, and the models desks used for options on bonds and swaps kept rates positive by making them lognormal: Black-Derman-Toy, then Black-Karasinski. The ECB's deposit rate went below zero on 11 June 2014 (L5.2.09: Normal volatility and negative rates), and lognormal rates were suddenly the wrong shape. They are still in use, often with a shift, and the bank's model validators keep one as a challenger to Hull-White (L5.3.08: Normal against lognormal dynamics). This lesson builds both on trees and fits Black-Karasinski to the same 5y × 5y swaption the next lesson compares.