Valuation guides

Callable, putable and extendible bonds explained

What bonds with embedded calls, puts and extensions are, why issuers use them, worked examples, the variations and how they are valued on short-rate trees.

Definition

A callable bond lets the issuer repay it early, on set dates and at set prices. A putable bond lets the holder sell it back to the issuer early. An extendible bond lets the holder or the issuer extend it past its first maturity. Each is a plain bond with an embedded interest rate option.

The issuer calls when rates have fallen, so it can refinance more cheaply, which caps the bond's price rise; investors are paid a higher coupon for giving up that upside. A put does the opposite and protects the holder when rates rise. Yield to worst, the lowest yield across all call dates and maturity, is the usual conservative quote.

History

Call provisions have been common in US corporate and municipal bonds since the 19th century, and most US corporate bonds issued before the 1990s were callable. Make-whole calls, which repay at the value of the remaining flows discounted at a small spread over Treasuries, became the norm for investment-grade bonds from the 1990s.

Valuing the embedded option properly needed a model of how rates move. The binomial and trinomial short-rate trees of Ho-Lee (1986), Black-Derman-Toy (1990) and Hull-White (1990, 1994) gave the industry its standard tool, and option-adjusted spread (OAS) became the way callable bonds are compared.

Examples

A callable corporate bond

A company issues a 10-year bond at 6%, callable at par after five years. If five-year rates fall to 4% by then, it calls the bond and refinances. Holders get par back and must reinvest at lower rates, which is why the bond paid a higher coupon than a non-callable one.

Option-adjusted spread

A callable bond trades at 101.2. Valued on a calibrated Hull-White tree, it needs a spread of 140bp over the curve to match that price; this is its OAS. Valued without the call at the same spread, it would be worth 103.0, so the call is worth 1.8 to the issuer.

Variations

Callable bond
Issuer calls on a schedule of dates and prices.
Putable bond
Holder puts back on set dates, usually at par.
Extendible bond
The holder or issuer can extend the maturity, sometimes at a new coupon.
Make-whole call
Repays at the discounted value of the remaining flows; rarely worth exercising for rate reasons.

Valuation methods

The bond is valued backwards on a short-rate tree fitted to today's curve. At each call or put date, the value at a node is the lower (call) or higher (put) of continuing and exercising. The tree's volatility is calibrated to swaptions, and a constant spread over the tree's rates, the OAS, is solved to match a market price.

The model choice sets the shape of the rate distribution. Hull-White has normally distributed rates. Black-Karasinski and Black-Derman-Toy keep rates positive with lognormal short rates. CIR++ uses a square-root process shifted to fit the curve. Effective duration and convexity come from revaluing at the same OAS with the curve moved up and down.

Hull-White short rate

drt=(θ(t)−a rt) dt+σ dWtdr_t = \big(\theta(t) - a\,r_t\big)\,dt + \sigma\,dW_t

θ(t) fits today's curve, a is the mean reversion speed and σ the volatility of the short rate.

Models on RiskAtoms

InstrumentPricing models
Callable bond
Hull-White trees and finite differences
Black-Karasinski lognormal short-rate tree
Black-Derman-Toy lognormal short-rate tree
CIR++ square-root short-rate tree
Putable bond
Hull-White trees and finite differences
Black-Karasinski lognormal short-rate tree
Black-Derman-Toy lognormal short-rate tree
CIR++ square-root short-rate tree
Extendible bond
Hull-White trees and finite differences
Black-Karasinski lognormal short-rate tree
Black-Derman-Toy lognormal short-rate tree
CIR++ square-root short-rate tree