Valuation guides

Securities lending explained

What securities lending is, why it exists, a worked example and how loan fees and rebates are valued.

Definition

In securities lending, the owner of shares or bonds lends them to a borrower, usually to cover a short sale or for settlement, in exchange for collateral and a fee. Legal title passes to the borrower, who must return equivalent securities and pay over any dividends or coupons as manufactured payments.

With non-cash collateral, the borrower pays a lending fee. With cash collateral, the lender reinvests the cash and pays the borrower a rebate rate below the market rate; the difference is the lender's return.

History

Securities lending grew in the 1960s and 1970s in the US, alongside short selling and the back-office problems of the paperwork crisis. Custodian banks built lending programmes for pension funds and insurers. In 2008 losses on cash collateral reinvestment at some lenders, notably AIG, showed the hidden risks, and regulators later required more reporting under SFTR in Europe.

Examples

Lending against cash

A pension fund lends shares worth 10 million against 10.2 million of cash collateral. It reinvests the cash at 5.30% and pays the borrower a rebate of 4.90%, earning 0.40% a year on the collateral, about 40,800.

Variations

Loan against non-cash collateral
A fee paid on the value lent.
Loan against cash collateral
A rebate paid on the cash.
Hard-to-borrow (special) loans
High fees, or negative rebates, on scarce securities.

Valuation methods

The fee or the rebate spread is accrued over the loan's term and discounted. Collateral margin compares the collateral with the value of the securities on loan, including manufactured dividends, and flags any shortfall.

Models on RiskAtoms

InstrumentPricing models
Securities loan (cash or non-cash collateral)
Securities lending fee and rebate