Valuation guides

Employee stock options explained

What employee stock options are, how accounting rules changed their valuation, an example and how the Hull-White lattice values them.

Definition

Employee stock options (ESOs) give staff the right to buy company shares at a fixed price, usually for ten years. They differ from traded options: they vest only after a waiting period, are forfeited if the employee leaves before vesting, cannot be sold, and are usually exercised early once they are well in the money, because employees want to diversify.

History

Stock options became a large part of executive pay in the US from the 1980s. After years of debate, accounting standards (FAS 123R in the US in 2004 and IFRS 2 in 2004) required companies to expense them at fair value. Hull and White (2004) proposed the lattice model with an early exercise multiple and exit rates that many companies now use.

Examples

Early exercise

If employees typically exercise when the share price is 2.5 times the strike, a ten-year option struck at 50 is exercised as soon as the share reaches 125, which makes it worth less than a ten-year traded option.

Variations

Employee stock option
Vesting, exits, an early exercise multiple and dilution.
Restricted stock and SARs
Shares or cash-settled appreciation rights with similar vesting.

Valuation methods

The Hull-White lattice is a binomial tree in which the option cannot be exercised before vesting, is lost if the employee leaves before vesting, is exercised early when the share reaches a multiple of the strike, and is exercised or lost on leaving after vesting. Dilution from new shares is taken into account.

Models on RiskAtoms

InstrumentPricing models
Employee stock option (ASC 718, IFRS 2)
Hull-White employee stock option lattice
Binomial tree (Cox-Ross-Rubinstein)
Black-Scholes