Valuation guides

Crack, spark and calendar spread options explained

What commodity spread options are, how refiners and power producers use them, a worked example and how they are valued.

Definition

A spread option pays on the difference between two prices. A crack spread is the difference between refined products and crude oil, the refiner's margin. A spark spread is the difference between power prices and the cost of the gas to generate it. A calendar spread is the difference between two delivery months of the same commodity.

History

NYMEX listed crack spread options in 1994, and spark spreads became a standard measure of power plant value as electricity markets were liberalised in the 1990s. Margrabe (1978) priced the zero-strike exchange option exactly, and Kirk (1995) gave the approximation the energy market still uses for non-zero strikes.

Examples

A spark spread

A gas plant with a heat rate of 7 turns 7 MMBtu of gas into 1 MWh of power. With power at 60 dollars per MWh and gas at 3, the spark spread is 60 − 7 × 3 = 39. A call on the spark spread is the value of the option to run the plant.

Variations

Crack and spark spread options
On two different commodities, with a ratio.
Calendar spread option
On two delivery months.

Valuation methods

The exact two-asset price is computed by integrating Black-Scholes over one asset's lognormal distribution, with Kirk's approximation alongside for comparison. Correlation between the two prices is the key input, and its sensitivity is reported.

Kirk's approximation (call)

σK=σ12−2ρ σ1σ2 F2F2+K+σ22(F2F2+K)2\sigma_K = \sqrt{\sigma_1^2 - 2\rho\,\sigma_1\sigma_2\,\tfrac{F_2}{F_2+K} + \sigma_2^2\big(\tfrac{F_2}{F_2+K}\big)^2}

F₁ and F₂ are the two forwards, σ₁ and σ₂ their volatilities, ρ their correlation and K the strike; the call is Black-76 on F₁ against F₂ + K.

Models on RiskAtoms

InstrumentPricing models
Crack and spark spread option
Exact two-asset spread (conditional Black-76)
Kirk spread approximation
Monte Carlo (correlated lognormal)
Calendar spread option
Exact two-asset spread (conditional Black-76)
Kirk spread approximation
Schwartz one-factor commodity
Schwartz-Smith two-factor
Gabillon two-factor