Core Path · L1.1.05

Who trades: market participants

10 minMarketsParticipants

By the end you will be able to

  1. 1Identify hedgers, speculators, arbitrageurs, market makers and end investors by why they trade.
  2. 2Explain how a hedge locks in a price, and who takes on the risk the hedger gives up.
  3. 3Explain how market makers and arbitrageurs keep markets liquid and prices in line.
  4. 4Recognise that one firm can play several of these roles.

Why it matters

Every trade has two sides. When a farmer sells next year's wheat at a fixed price, someone else agrees to buy it. Who would want to, and why? Knowing who is on the other side of a trade is the first step to knowing where the risk ends up.

Core explanation

Five reasons to trade

Markets are crowded with banks, funds, companies and individuals. A useful way to sort them is not by who they are but by why they trade. There are five main motives.

  • Hedgers already have a risk from their business, and trade to reduce it. An airline worries that fuel will get dearer; a farmer worries that wheat will get cheaper.
  • Speculators take on risk on purpose, because they expect to profit. The word sounds negative, but speculators are often the ones willing to take the risk hedgers want to shed.
  • Arbitrageurs look for the same thing priced differently in two places. They buy the cheap one and sell the dear one, and in doing so push the prices back together.
  • Market makers stand ready to buy and to sell at any moment, quoting both prices. They earn the spread between them, and in return give everyone else liquidity: someone to trade with right now.
  • End investors buy to hold, for years or decades: pension funds, insurers, sovereign wealth funds and households saving for retirement. Most of the world's savings belong to them.

Two questions tell the five apart: how long does the trader hold the position, and does the trade add risk or remove it? Click around the map.

ExploreWhy they trade: a map of motives

addsnoneremovesrisksecondsmonthsdecadeshow long they holdMarket makerArbitrageurSpeculatorHedgerEnd investor

Hedger

Aims to

Protect a business against a price move it cannot control.

Risk

Reduces risk it already has, giving up some upside to remove the downside.

For example

An airline fixing next year's fuel price; a farmer fixing the price of the next harvest.

One market, every role

Here is how the five meet in a single market: futures on wheat, traded on the Chicago Board of Trade. A futures contract fixes today a price for wheat delivered later.

Step throughA season in the wheat futures market

1 / 6

Farmer

A hedger sells

In spring, a Kansas farmer expects to harvest 50,000 bushels. She fears prices will fall by summer, so she sells futures at $6.00 a bushel. Her selling price is now locked in.

Hedger

Roles, not job titles. A large bank can make markets for clients in the morning, hedge its own loan book at lunch and take a view on the yen in the afternoon. When you see a trade, ask what it is for. That tells you which role is being played, and whether risk is being reduced or taken on.

Sort itWhich role is being played?

0 of 7 right
  1. A coffee chain fixes the price of next year's beans with futures.

  2. A hedge fund buys Brazilian real because it expects the currency to strengthen.

  3. A firm quotes buy and sell prices on 500 shares all day, holding each position for seconds.

  4. A trader sees an ETF priced below the shares it holds, buys the ETF and sells the shares.

  5. A teachers' pension fund buys a 30-year bond to match pensions due in 30 years.

  6. A Japanese exporter sells dollars forward to fix the yen value of next year's US sales.

  7. A retail investor buys shares in a chip maker before its results, hoping to sell next week.

Worked example

The farmer's hedge in numbers

The farmer sells futures on 50,000 bushels at $6.00. One CBOT wheat contract covers 5,000 bushels, so she sells 10 contracts. Prices are in US dollars per bushel. To keep it simple, the futures price and the cash price are equal at harvest, and fees and margin are ignored.

Two harvests, one locked-in price

Step 1 of 5
  1. 1

    Prices fall to $5.00

    She sells her crop for 50,000 × $5.00 = $250,000.

Regulatory lens

Regulators treat these roles differently. In US commodity futures, the CFTC sets limits on how large a speculator's position may be, while genuine hedgers can apply for exemptions. The EU applies position limits to commodity derivatives under MiFID II. Market makers on many exchanges sign agreements that oblige them to keep quoting, in return for lower fees.

Looking ahead: the institutions behind these roles, from banks to hedge funds and pension funds, are the subject of Module 1.2.

Sparks

SparkRice futures in eighteenth-century Osaka
Merchants at the Dojima rice market in Osaka traded contracts on future rice deliveries, and in 1730 the shogunate officially recognised the market. It is often cited as one of the first organised futures markets, built for the same reason as Chicago's: farmers and merchants wanted certainty about prices.
SparkWhen speculation tried to corner a market
In 1979 the Hunt brothers of Texas built up huge holdings of silver and silver futures. The price rose from around $6 an ounce at the start of 1979 to almost $50 in January 1980. Exchanges then raised margins and restricted new buying, and the price collapsed, most dramatically on “Silver Thursday”, 27 March 1980.

Key takeaways

  • Sort participants by why they trade: hedgers, speculators, arbitrageurs, market makers and end investors.
  • Hedgers reduce a risk they already have; speculators take risk on purpose and often take the hedgers' risk.
  • Arbitrageurs keep related prices in line; market makers keep markets liquid and earn the spread.
  • End investors, such as pension funds, insurers and households, hold most of the world's savings and most of its long-term risk.
  • Roles describe trades, not firms: one bank can play several in a day.

Reaction

Check what stuck

Question 1 · objective 1

An airline buys oil futures to fix what it will pay for jet fuel next year. What is the airline doing?

Question 2 · objective 2

A farmer sells futures on 50,000 bushels of wheat at $6.00 a bushel. At harvest the price is $5.20, and futures and cash prices are equal. What does the farmer receive in total from the crop and the futures, in $?

$

Question 3 · objective 3

How does a market maker mainly earn its money?

Question 4 · objective 3

Gold is cheaper in London than in New York by more than the cost of moving it. A trader buys in London and sells in New York at the same moment. Who is this?

Question 5 · objective 4

A large bank quotes prices to clients all day, hedges its own interest rate risk, and bets on the euro. Which is true?

Glossary

Hedger
A trader who uses the market to reduce a risk it already has from its business or investments.
Speculator
A trader who takes on risk on purpose, to profit from a view on where prices will go.
Arbitrageur
A trader who profits from prices that are out of line, by buying the cheap one and selling the dear one at the same time.
Market maker
A firm that stands ready to buy and to sell, quoting both prices, and earns the gap between them.
End investor
An investor, such as a pension fund or a household, that buys to hold for a long-term return.
Futures
A standard exchange-traded contract to buy or sell something at a set price on a set future date.
Position
What a trader currently owns or owes in a market. A long position gains if the price rises; a short one gains if it falls.
Spread
The gap between the price a market maker will buy at (bid) and sell at (ask).
Liquidity
How quickly and cheaply you can trade without moving the price much.

Deep Dives & Origins

Deep Dives

  • Hull, Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives, Pearson, chapter 1, the section on types of traders. Intermediate.
  • Harris, Trading and Exchanges: Market Microstructure for Practitioners, Oxford University Press, 2003, the chapters on who trades and why. Intermediate.

Origins

  • Hull, J. C., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives, Pearson.
  • Harris, L., Trading and Exchanges: Market Microstructure for Practitioners, Oxford University Press, 2003.
  • CME Group, Chicago SRW wheat futures contract specifications.
  • US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, position limits rules; Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II), Article 57.

Watch this lesson

Video version

Prefer to watch? The same lesson as a 10-minute video will sit here, made from this page's script.